“Haunted History” Gettysburg Episode Surprisingly Does Not Disappoint

One of the locations featured in the "Ghosts of Gettysburg" episode Friday night.
One of the locations featured in the “Ghosts of Gettysburg” episode Friday night.

As the readers of this blog will note, I am the first person to admit when I am wrong, and sometimes, I do it happily. Such is the case upon viewing the first two episodes of H2’s Haunted History, a series, so far, which has avoided all of the hokeyness and nonsensical over-exaggeration that plagues current ghost shows. I was fully expecting this to be the case, since that is the direction television has taken. I knew the series would take us to historic places, but I figured that would be the extent of the “history”. Instead, aside from a much-needed modernization of special effects and camerawork, this series is modeling the original in that it actually combines a decent amount of historical background information intermixed with ghost stories, all while shying away from those hilarious and obviously staged “ghost hunts”, put on for the camera crew. While I must say that the first episode, dealing with ghosts surrounding the various locations of Charles Manson and his murders, suffered from a lack of direction and identity (it did not know what it wanted to be: a ghost show or a documentary on the Manson Murders; sometimes I thought it had too much information, and not enough ghost stories), this episode on Gettysburg hopefully brought the series into its own, setting the stage for what is to come. Below is my breakdown:

  • Even though I did enjoy the show, what I did not appreciate was the lifting of battle scenes from previous History Channel specials such as Gettysburg and America: The Story of Us. Granted, I was not expecting them to shoot new battle footage, but given the many reenactments that have been filmed over the years, the video of which is probably public domain, they would have been better off using that and fixing it with additional effects. Instead, we get to see a pretty tacky costuming job, with kepis full of those darned crossed-rifle insignias which did not exist until 1870, but happen to be available in every single gift shop in town (hmm…maybe that’s where the wardrobe department did their shopping?). I am also still trying to figure out why so many of those soldiers were wearing cowboy hats. Did the production run out of kepis? Okay, enough about the clothing…
  • The other thing that became pretty redundant was the over-emphasis on gore. The 51,000 number which was noted as being only dead in the commercial was now changed to “dead and dying”, within the episode itself—still very misleading, because not every wounded man succumbed to his injuries. They also showed the same clip over and over and over again of a bullet ripping through a solider, sending blood flying out his back. There were plenty of bloody scenes like that. Yes, the battle was ferocious and the carnage should be mentioned, but it got to the point where it seemed they were only using it for shock value.
  • Now to the actual ghost stories themselves. The beginning of the episode showed video footage taken by a woman on the battlefield that appears to show Confederate soldiers marching up an incline in the forest, as we can see them partially covered by the trees marching and turning. While the quality is not great, I have seen this video on several other specials, and no one, myself included, has been able to debunk it. I do not think she is lying, nor do I think it was intentionally faked. The only thing that comes to mind is that she mistook the ghosts for reenactors, but this was late at night, so the odds of that are slim. We then move to another story of a man who decided it was a good idea to play “Dixie” on his jaw-harp at the spot where many Union soldiers died. He then reported to have been dealt a debilitating blow, as in yes, being “shot” by a ghost. This is definitely a first for me, and while we know ghosts can cause pain or any number of feelings, I think we may have a slight exaggeration here. Speaking of shooting, it seems many of the ghosts in the Devil’s Den area are a bit hostile. A different woman captured an EVP of a Confederate soldier saying to her, “I am going to shoot you.” Maybe it was the same one that shot the other guy…
  • Haunted History did a great job of getting inside of these creepy locations, not like that’s a hard thing to do, given how desperate a lot of these places are for ghost business. But anyway, the Soldier’s National Museum, we find out, was actually an orphanage at the time of the battle, with a very brutal head-mistress at the helm. This building was the site of many atrocities, leading to the various ghosts and hauntings they experience. The stories were quite chilling, and all of it was new information to me, as I have passed the museum many times and never went inside. Other locations explored in the episode were the Jennie Wade House (my favorite tourist trap) and the Farnsworth House, which I believe to be one of the most haunted houses in the country—I know a couple who stays there annually, and they always experiences something while in their room.
  • Lastly, I just want to discuss something mentioned here that I am not sure if it is actually true. While discussing the relevance of the Jennie Wade and Farnsworth Houses to the battle itself, the assertion was made that the bullet that killed Wade was actually fired by a sharpshooter from the top window of the Farnsworth House. Now, I know that location is famous for being a “sniper’s lair” during the battle, but in all my years visiting, I never once heard someone make the connection. Maybe I just never paid attention or never delved further, but to someone out there who may know, was this just an assumption made by the people on this show, or are there some facts backing it up? I also was always under the impression that Wade was killed accidentally, but the vibe I got after watching this last night was that the shot may have been fired into the house intentionally. If someone has any more information on this, please leave it in the comment section.
  • Overall, I thought this was a very good episode despite some of the shortcomings. The camerawork and editing gave it a very in-your-face feel, as noted by the person I was watching it with. I thought the balance between history and ghosts was more than fair and this makes me excited for the episodes to come.

11 thoughts on ““Haunted History” Gettysburg Episode Surprisingly Does Not Disappoint

  1. Chris Evans

    Excellent review. I agree. I thought it was a good episode also.

    I was glad that there were more Ghost stories than in the first episode which was used almost as another rehash of the story of the Manson murders.

    I wish the Gettysburg episode could have included more stories from the battlefield and I wish they somehow could have included one of my favorite stories (though I know it was on the first ‘Ghosts of Gettysburg back in the ’90s) of the administrators from Pennsylvania college descending into the hell of a Civil War hospital.

    Chris

    1. Yes that was a great story. It was also featured on an episode of UNSOLVED MYSTERIES, hosted by the legendary Robert Stack. To this day, that remains the most chilling of all encounters.

      Perhaps there will be another Gettysburg episode down the line, if it goes into another season (which I am sure it will). As you know, the original HAUNTED HISTORY had two episodes as well, in different seasons. I am eager to see how this series progresses. It is far from perfect but way better than I expected.

      1. Chris Evans

        I agree. The beckoning of the doctor to the administrators to please come and help him gives me the creeps.

        Another story I thought was excellent in the original ‘Ghosts of Gettysburg’ series was the Confederate soldier that was buried alive under the Confederate dead and when he was found after the battle he was raving mad and died soon after. His ghost haunted the house for over a century until it was exorcised. That was a very chilling story and done very well on the recreation of it for the show.

        Chris

      2. I never heard the one about the soldier getting buried alive. Sounds creepy! Wish I saw that episode. I’m thinking now that I never saw the sequel to the original “Ghosts of Gettysburg”.

      3. Chris Evans

        Yes, your right that it was on the sequel episode ‘More Ghosts of Gettysburg’. They should have made more as they were both excellently done.

        What made the fate of the Confederate soldier so horrible is that he was pinned under a pile of Confederate dead for a couple of days in the July heat in this barn behind the Confederate lines and no one could hear his cries for help. It was truly horrifying the way it was depicted. The program said that the Northern troops felt so bad for him that when he was found and soon passed away they buried him in a coffin even though those were in short supply.

        Nesbitt tells the story in detail in his book ‘Ghosts of Gettysburg III’.

        Chris

  2. Chris Evans

    I did notice that they used a little reenactment footage from their ’90s documentaries like ‘Civil War Combat’ and ‘Unknown Civil War’.

    Mark Nesbitt in his excellent book series on the ‘Ghosts of Gettysburg’ has the backstory of the Soldier’s National Museum. He tells the whole sordid history of the brutal headmistress at the orphanage and many chilling stories. Also, that photo that they kept showing of the front of the building in the 1860s includes U.S. Grant when he was visiting the site postwar.

    Chris

  3. Pingback: Gettysburg ghosts | ~ Morgan Le Fay's Blog ~

  4. Hank Manns

    Enjoyed the episode. However they keep mistakenly state that approximately 60,000 soldiers died during the three day battle. Incorrect! Approximately 4,700 Confederate and 3,200 Union soldiers were killed during the battle.

  5. POint on review. I like the “old” Haunted History better, mainly for atmosphere. These new stories more like history documentaries. Very tuff to find good shoews about the paranormal.

  6. Kathy

    When I tours the Jennie Wade House the guide told us that the sharpshooters, in the Farnsworth House, had been testing their rifles and shooting at the door as a target.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s